After a couple of rather annoying discoveries, the Selfish Seamstress has come to a rather rash conclusion. There are two kinds of people on the internet: 1) my dear, wonderful readers and 2) idiots.
Okay, I realize that my logic here is flawed and that there are probably a couple of non-idiot internet users besides you guys, but DAMN if there aren’t some serious idiots out there.
For example, dear reader Polly (NOT an idiot, instead rather awesome) alerted me to this:
That’s right- someone’s trying to sell my pattern for the Coffee Date Dress on eBay! For £7.50! Good job, eBay user lorriange, with your two negative feedbacks as a seller in the past 6 months, way to do your own work. I bet you tried to cheat off of other kids’ math tests when you were little because it was easier than learning how to add and subtract for yourself. Sorry to see that no one bid on your pathetic little auction. You know why? Because people who sew know that it’s available for FREE ON THE INTERNET. If an idiot like you could find it, so can anyone else, duh. (Also, possibly because the pattern is not all that interesting.)
Here’s the description the seller provides with the auction:
“BUST 32-42 MULTI SIZE SEWING PATTERN. ELEGANT DESIGNER SHIFT DRESS. AVAILABLE READY PRINTED ON A4 PAPER READY TO TAPE AND CUT OR SAVED ON CD FOR YOU TO USE OVER AND OVER.”
Ugh. first of all, it’s SIZE 32-42, not BUST 32-42. Also, it’s not a shift dress, it’s a fitted bodice with an A-line skirt. And as for printing it or saving it to CD, I’m going to guess that lazyass lorriange probably just sends you a link to where you can download it from me because she can’t be bothered.
Now one idiot on the internet could be an isolated incident, but two idiots is certainly indicative of an epidemic. Awesome reader Hussain pointed out that a photo of me in my bubble wrap tutu was used to illustrate a Wikihow article on how to make a bubble wrap tutu!
For serious? I mean, it’s a Wikihow article, for jeeb’s sake. Why would you even bother to put together a tutorial on doing something if you’re not actually going to do it and use your own photographs of it?? This is like inventing a cookie recipe, posting it on the web, and then showing a photo of a package of Chips Ahoy! next to it. IDIOTS.
Also, seriously, if you want to make a decent bubble wrap tutu, don’t use the Wikihow article. They actually tell you to use glue on the bubble wrap. Glue! I mean, use the tutorial if you want your tutu to fall apart within minutes. Or if you want it to look like this (the finished project they show at the end of the step-by-step instructions- look, it’s exactly like mine! No wonder they used my picture as the title image!):
Oh, and if you want, you can also make an accompanying “wand”:
Niiiiiiice. It’s sheer crafting genius, like those intricately painted Ukrainian Easter eggs, or rose point lacemaking. Nice to see a modern revival of the lost art of “putting a wad of garbage on top of a stick.”
In all seriousness though, sigh. Sometimes it makes me want to stop putting my stuff out there, knowing that other people who can’t be bothered to do their own work are just going to claim my creative efforts as their own ideas, their own property, their own stuff to sell, their own stuff to show off. I’m not talking about laws and legality and intellectual property – for those of you who have your mouse pointer poised on the “Leave a Comment” link, ready to point out that no laws have been broken- I know. And yes, I am fully aware of what one opens oneself up to by putting things on the internet. It doesn’t make it less annoying to discover yourself front and center on some random eBay auction and see your precious hard work appropriated, diluted, and misrepresented.
So there you have it- proof that my readers (thank you, Polly and Hussain!) are smart and wonderful, and that everyone else on the internet is an idiot. Though I suppose if they’re downloading my patterns to sell and copying my pictures to illustrate their own sad little tutorials, they’d have to have been visiting my blog also… hrmmm. I’m going to need to come up with a new theory to explain this then. Until then, how about you? Any uncreative asshats exploited your creativity lately? Do tell!
47 comments
Comments feed for this article
March 24, 2012 at 4:18 am
Bratling
Elaine, you do realize that a decent graphics program can add a watermark to your photographs if you’re so inclined to do it, don’t you? Also, you can make it impossible to download your pictures with a line of code, too. I’ve done it in the past on my fic website…. You’ll have to look it up, though–my HTML is rusty.
March 24, 2012 at 4:25 am
selfishseamstress
Thanks for the tips- I was already thinking after these incidents that I’ll probably start watermarking my images, though it’s a shame to have to from an aesthetic standpoint. I know that you can code the images such that people don’t have the ability to do a right-click download, but it unfortunately doesn’t prevent screen captures. Also, I’m not sure if wordpress supports it because it’s Javascript, not just straight HTML :( I may start watermarking though- though, ugh, I hate the thought of having to go back and retroactively watermark all of my previous images.
March 24, 2012 at 4:29 am
Rennai
I would like to point out that the so called skirt in the finish project picture is only staying on the model due to the fact that she is holding it with her hand and her arm. What the! Its not a tutu.
March 24, 2012 at 4:34 am
selfishseamstress
Oooh, you could be right! Then again, it might just be held up by all of the magic coming from her wand :)
March 24, 2012 at 4:44 am
craftcove
But it is against the law if it’s your pattern!
And it’s very immoral!
March 24, 2012 at 4:51 am
A Peppermint Penguin
you say no laws have been broken, but they have! your pictures are yours under copyright law, using them without your permission breaks said law. Copying your ideas, or misrepresenting ideas, no – you are stuck with that one.
March 24, 2012 at 4:52 am
Jennifer
This irks me!! What are you going to do? Have you written them a nasty email?
Great tags by the way. They made me lol.
March 24, 2012 at 5:15 am
craftcove
I’m pretty sure you can complain to the actual websites hosting these. They are supposed to remove them immediately.
A nasty message wouldn’t go astray either!
The pattern and the images are your own personal property and nobody has the right to sell them or use them in any way you don’t want them to.
March 24, 2012 at 5:59 am
Jacqui
Man, why do thieves and cheaters like this have to be so stupid? It’s hard to feel as angry at them as I should (because yes they have broken copyright law by using your images) when the results are so tragically lame. My six year old could do a better bubble skirt and wand than that! I don’t think I’d really want to know if someone had ripped me off like that, or maybe I would, I don’t know… I think if anyone ever does though, I’d hope for a better-quality job than these!
March 24, 2012 at 6:28 am
Valerie
That is just so rude of those copy cats. Complain to the website hosts.
March 24, 2012 at 6:51 am
Emily
Lovely Selfish, please don’t let these uncreative, inconsequential turds change the fact that you create, you write, and you enjoy the admiration of so many followers. Asshats indeed. They are, as another commenter said, hilariously, tragically lame. And I know I’m not the only one of your followers whose anger at these con artists is consoled only by the fact that their end results are horrific. Keep doing what you’re doing, Selfish–you’ve got an army armed with intellect and pinking shears behind you!
March 24, 2012 at 7:14 am
Liara
Those people are just ridiculously lame. The pattern stealer’s former teachers must be so proud. Clearly she learned the “rule” that if you change a few words (whether they’re changed correctly or not) it’s not plagarism.
March 24, 2012 at 7:30 am
tassadit
I suppose you must have seen this, too? (scroll down the page)
http://lorriange.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=24&Itemid=42
March 24, 2012 at 12:04 pm
selfishseamstress
Argghhhhh- thanks for letting me know. I recognize quite a number of other “borrowed” work from other people there too. BLEH.
March 24, 2012 at 7:31 am
Melody
I have a pet photography business and it is disgusting to discover the abandon with which people steal my work. I’ve had to send two cease and desist letters already this year. A pet photographer friend who’s also a graphic designer sent over 100 of them last year and had an incident where she found out that a logo-design company was using her work, unauthorized and illegally, to create logos for other people.
Fortunately, the two people who ripped off my material were total losers – they were indeed idiots and their work was abysmal. I found that the people who steal one’s work are never ever going to get far with it. But, still, it’s enraging and violating and I know exactly how you feel.
March 24, 2012 at 7:34 am
Melody
My sister is a copyright attorney, so my letters to these people are scary because I am able to lawyer-up from the very first communication and she’s happy to do it.
March 24, 2012 at 11:37 am
Pammie
Melody, concur! I’d say – Cease and Desist for causes of action including various copyright violations and the tort claim of misappropriation – I put that below too in my comments. How ridiculous!
March 24, 2012 at 8:04 am
Pam ~Off The Cuff~
Some people have no scruples!
I have been ripped off so many times that now I “watermark” all my tutorial pics. …and my “attorney friend” helps me out in the same way Melody’s sister does :)
March 24, 2012 at 8:05 am
Karen Kelly
I agree with A Peppermint Penguin. They have broken the laws by using your images. Selfish, this is one of the huge problems with the Internet, and with the latest rage among many crafters, Pinterest. Sorry to slightly change the subject, but it is related. I refer you to this article on Business Insider (and there are others who cover this, including the Wall Street Journal): http://articles.businessinsider.com/2012-02-28/tech/31106641_1_repinning-copyright-entire-image Pinterest means more stealing from great blogs like yours. It may be unintentional, but it is something to think about.
March 24, 2012 at 8:05 am
ParisGrrl
Surely you see enough plagiarism at work; you shouldn’t have to come home to it as well. But don’t let a few badger-brains get you down…craft a killer cease-and-desist letter for them, and please keep inspiring all of us who love [and respect] you!
March 24, 2012 at 8:35 am
Simona
I find this disgusting! You are kind to share with us some lovely patterns and tutorials and some ‘bright head’ just wants to profit. I hope not to many people fall for it though.
March 24, 2012 at 8:37 am
Elaray
Even at my advanced age, I’m often surprised at how stupid some people can be! Right now, the most I’m able to do with my pictures is crop my head off. You post is yet another wake up call for me to be very cautious about what I put on my blog.
March 24, 2012 at 8:56 am
Andrea
Stealing other’s creative property is rampant on the Internet. It is despicable and frustrating, and I wish there was a way to stop it. Similar theft has happened to my daughters artwork. :(
March 24, 2012 at 9:33 am
sewtellme1113
This is actually worse than the girl who was making and selling the coffee date dress as her own on Etsy. I don’t know what’s wrong with people, how stupid can someone be to use YOUR image and think you won’t discover that the ripped you off!
March 24, 2012 at 9:55 am
Mikhaela
Ugh. Watermarking doesn’t stop crop-happy jerks though. I’ve had cartoons of mine with clear watermarks and copyright notices in them stolen, cropped and photoshopped to remove my info and used as illustrations on various sites. Unfortunately I think Pinterest adds to this image-grabbing free for all. As for Wikihow, like eHow I believe it is a link farm website, where contributors get paid crap to write articles based on currently popular search terms. Oh and worst image stealing story I have– a woman who was faking a pregnancy and asking people online to help her pay for prenatal treatments stole an ultrasound photo of my daughter from Flickr. One of my facebook friends alerted me.
March 24, 2012 at 9:50 am
kathyh
once I got over the fact that I somehow missed your post of the bubblewrap tutu, I then searched for the @#$Ebay seller so I could figure out how to negative-ize her – with my magic wand (I glued it together in one minute or less!!!).
There has been some very thought-provoking blog posts regarding pinterest and people re-pinning your images (especially of kids). I have been contemplating the additional time to throw my own photos thru photoshop to add a watermark. Time which could be better spent making tutu’s out of bubblewrap with accompanying TIARA(with real gemstones!!!) and maybe some wonder woman arm bands. . . .
March 24, 2012 at 10:44 am
Carolyn
I don’t have nearly the strong online presence you have, selfish, so this has only happened to me once (that I know of). But it’s irksome to the extreme, and even made me feel ever-so-slightly violated. I think it was because of how much work and how personal I felt about the item whose image was ripped off to help someone sell their own (shoddy) work. I engaged in a historical repro project a few years ago as an aside to my Master’s thesis. I made a blog of the project – like a really detailed sewing journal – because I was doing it as period (mid-18th century) correct as I was able in order to gain some experience of working life at that time. I made a lady’s riding habit as part of the project and must have spent at least 100hrs handsewing it (probably not including the 25 ‘deathshead’ buttons I made with silk thread by hand). A visitor to my blog alerted me that images of the finished ensemble were on an etsy shop page offering it as available for custom order. The seller described my work as a museum reproduction. Mildly flattering description? Yes. Still totally un-cool. I wrote to her that I was non-plussed she didn’t give proper credit, though I acknowledged that at least she didn’t claim it as her own work. I simply asked that she give proper credit, and next time ask before using someone’s photo. No response (of course). So I offered to let Etsy know that she may be in violation of their regulations. I got a pretty snarky response (of course) but the images suddenly disappeared from the listing. Go figure!
March 24, 2012 at 11:07 am
Reethi
Ah, you know you’ve arrived when random eBay sellers are ripping off your image. (I’m joking, I would be pretty furious if this happened, and yes, people really are idiots.)
March 24, 2012 at 11:35 am
Pammie
Selfish (Elaine),
I believe at a minimum you have a potential cause of action for misappropriation – at a minimum I would send out a Cease and Desist letter to both ebay, Wiki and the actual vendors. And, arguably if you wanted to go this far – you could enjoin the parties from using your images (temporary injunction, etc.) . . .
I’m sorry this happened to you. Shocking.
March 24, 2012 at 12:02 pm
Next Post « The Selfish Seamstress
[…] on the idiot issue: eagle-eyed reader Tassadit pointed out that the idiot who’s trying to sell my sewing […]
March 24, 2012 at 12:02 pm
Idiots on the Internet Part II: Seriously, Lorriange?? « The Selfish Seamstress
[…] on the idiot issue: eagle-eyed reader Tassadit pointed out that the idiot who’s trying to sell my sewing […]
March 24, 2012 at 12:14 pm
arenee2
I just tried to find both the dress (so I could leave a negative comment) and the seller on ebay, but neither came up. Hopefully, this means ebay has booted them off. So sorry this happened to you SS.
March 24, 2012 at 1:16 pm
kristinm100
Terrible violation notwithstanding – you have described it in such a way that I actually laughed out loud at a couple of points. Honestly, Elaine, I wouldn’t want to cross you :-) I have no doubt you will find excellent ways to restore justice. Starting with this post.
March 25, 2012 at 11:36 am
L
I would be livid, I tried the website but it seems to be down. Using your image is despicable.
March 26, 2012 at 3:57 pm
symondezyn
Ugh, what an IDIOT!! I’d be soooooo angry!! It would be all I could do not to send a scathingly acid email to the perpetrator…. hopefully karma will do that for you though :(
March 27, 2012 at 6:29 am
dizzy
They can’t lawfully sell your pattern though.
March 29, 2012 at 12:04 am
Jane Elise
If you send ebay a link to your blog and your free pattern on burdastyle they will take down the sale from ebay. I had to do that for an item I was selling and I took my own photographs and wrote my own copy and they stole it so I complained and whoosh it was gone.
March 29, 2012 at 11:34 am
dollsaga
its unfortunate that someone out there wants to use others works to make profits.
instead of accusing everyone else is an idiot except your wonderful online readers (such logic is very idiotic, are people who invented internet but do not read your blog idiots?), the right thing to do is to contact ebay or the seller directly and have the listing removed. usually the seller would remove it within a few second after being told he has violated eBay policy and your copyrights.
March 29, 2012 at 11:45 am
selfishseamstress
wow, guess you missed the multiple jokes i made about my own obviously sarcastic logic. yes, not everyone is an idiot. i hope most of my readers know that already, and understand that i know that as well.
i contacted wikihow and ebay days ago, but thanks for the sage advice.
March 29, 2012 at 5:31 pm
craftcove
Why say that! Surely you understand what she meant! She gives this information and patterns for free for anyone to use, and someone abuses her generosity! Wouldn’t you be angry? It shouldn’t have happened in the first place.
April 19, 2012 at 6:59 pm
Ashley
Loved this post! You made me laugh. I hate jumping through hoops to just have mine be mine and not feel abused by sharing. But this is life. I see nothing wrong in venting especially when it makes me laugh.
April 23, 2012 at 7:51 pm
theperfectnose
My sympathies are with you! Etsy is rife with this sort of thing. Practically every other week I see dress patterns and book scans being sold as ‘pdf versions’. I mean, here’s someone selling Harriet Pepin’s classic drafting book that is still being published and is under copyright (the Centre for Pattern Design stocks the original) and you can’t report it! Etsy terms state that in order for them to look at copyright violations the holder of the copyright themself has to report it to Etsy (and not through the ‘report this item’ link either (which they’ve now moved to the bottom of the page made really hard to find). The other end of the spectrum of course, is people making frivolous copyright claims against items they have no intellectual copyright over and Etsy running to delete said listings just because they now have lawyers up their collective like so. But there is some justice in the world, (sometimes) so chin up! ;D
August 11, 2012 at 11:37 am
Justine sew country chick
This has become a real problem now and Pinterest is making it worse! Miss your blog, BTW.
September 27, 2012 at 4:07 pm
Demented Seamstress
Gah! Such incredible stupidity. Their lame tutu looks NOTHING like yours, yours is nice and poofy, and attached to a bodice like a proper tutu.
Theirs is sad and limp, it looks like a sheet of bubble wrap with a few stupidly small pleats, because that’s what it is!
How could anyone be taken in by that tutorial?
October 18, 2012 at 8:43 am
Talon
omg, you are hilarious.
November 20, 2012 at 4:50 pm
black friday 2012 deals
Your style is so unique in comparison to other people I’ve read stuff from. Many thanks for posting when you’ve got the opportunity, Guess I will just bookmark this blog.
December 13, 2015 at 10:28 pm
Amber
Your post, made me laugh so hard. I love the flow of your writing and raw wittiness. (btw, I won’t be claiming it as my own and sharing it anywhere, lol) Ugh, it’s erkks me to see that their are actually people out there that do this kind of straight BS. But, they are out there. Just today I had to un join a beloved facebook group that we bought and sold cloth diapers through (just a bunch of mom’s btw) because a group of moron’s hacked the Admins accounts and then deleted them as admins and it has just been insanity ever since. They are extremely creepy too. Which, obviously if they had the smarts to hack the account, the aren’t really moron’s but they certainly are assheads, and not to mention pretty useless. I mean they hacked an account that moms use to buy/sell diapers, What are you really getting out of that besides being annoying? Anyways, I sympathize with your plight and hope that all the above suggestion help to keep stuff like this from happening in the future. Isn’t there a way to prevent your pattern from redistributed once it’s downloaded? I could swear I’ve gotten things before that weren’t able to be resent to someone else, but I may be wrong. Good luck!