Many a hobby seamstress, me included, takes advantage of her skill to knock off something she covets but cannot afford. Currently this is not easy for me; it takes quite a lot of effort and trial and error, and the replica always ends up somewhat approximate, which is usually fine. But it’s skill that I would like to become very good at because it’s something of a sewing superhero skill in my opinion, to be able to see something you want and then really just “make your own” like it’s no big deal. [Aside: Anyone who has just started to sew will find that when she tells her friends about her new hobby, they will immediately begin gathering up photos of designer clothes and asking if she can make this for them. The answer should always be NO. Trust me on this one. Unless you can make it look exactly like the Dior she wants, you’re setting yourself up for a situation in which you hand the garment to your friend and you see her face fall in disappointment for a second before she brightly says, “Thank you!”]
In an interesting turn of events, I happened upon a picture of this capelet/vest/jacket thing and now I think I’d like to make one. (I’ve cooled on the Burda cape idea, which I’m taking as an indication that I probably wouldn’t wear it much either if I were to make it.)
I don’t remember where I first saw the picture, but as it turns out, this rather sophisticated garment is from that beloved Jank Mecca for teenyboppers, Forever 21! Granted, F21 puts out some cute stuff (and why shouldn’t they considering that they themselves are knockoff experts?) but I don’t think of them as my go-to place for chic office separates. They’re out of my size online, but then again, I’m not sure if I’d buy it even if they did have my size- too hit or miss with the fabric and quality. And it looks like it could be an fun draft and good practice. So now I guess I’m into knocking off cheap stuff too? I’d like to say I’m taking a design I like and making a better quality version, but truth be told, I don’t think my workmanship is really any better than F21’s yet. Those little kids are pretty handy with a sewing machine and I’m no couturier.
In keeping with the F21 theme, I’ve got a fabric which seems like the right color and drape but somehow looks cheaper than I want it to :) This Vera Wang Lavender Label that I bought during one of the Fabric.com sales was described as a wool and nylon twill, which it is, but somehow I was thinking it would be of a pant or suit weight when I ordered it. In actuality it’s somewhat spongier and fluffier, better for a light jacket, weird for pants. And somehow the 20% nylon component is very noticeable- a plasticky sparkle like that of carpet or acrylic yarn. Hard to tell from the photo they had on the website:
In any case, it’s the only thing in my stash that is really suitable, and I don’t expect this will be a garment I’ll wear every day, so it’s not really worth buying any more fabric for it.
So, it’s come to this. The Selfish Seamstress is making knockoffs of cheap mall store garments. Wish me luck!
34 comments
Comments feed for this article
January 27, 2010 at 9:31 am
amber
I thought I knew where this post was going just from the title – I was correct. ;) Too funny. For what it’s worth, I’m willing to bet your version will be even better than the F21 garment. I know lots of folks that have luck with that store, but the few times I’ve been in, I’ve walked out with a bag of cheap (aka disposable) and fun accessories and that’s about it. Most of the clothes are a bit wonky IMO, which I’m guessing will not be an adjective to describe your garment. Good luck!
January 27, 2010 at 9:36 am
CGCouture
Well, be sure to post your pattern when you figure it out for those of us less talented. ;-) Because that is very cute!
January 27, 2010 at 10:00 am
Reethi
I’m 5ft tall, and nothing in Forever 21 fits me – so you can always tell yourself you are knocking off Forever 21 in order to get impeccable fit. (Also, evidently, 21 year olds show an alarming amount of cleavage, because nothing I’ve tried on there is even remotely work-appropriate. Unless said-place-of-work is Hooters.)
January 27, 2010 at 10:09 am
Anonymous
Or unless you live where I live, where apparently the general public feel compelled to wear clothes that would make a prostitute think twice… and do so whilst working, oh let’s say, as the receptionist at a medical clinic. Or a secretary in a law office. Or, really, anywhere. The cleavage here is UNbelievable in general society. (And I’m not by any means prudish, but good lord I do not need to see the nipples of the receptionist at my insurance agent’s. Really. I don’t.)
January 27, 2010 at 4:17 pm
Monica Smith
next time tell her she has incredible nipples
January 27, 2010 at 10:03 am
The Cupcake Goddess
I still love it! Your scheming is brilliant! I do completely agree with you about the making for your friends. Its not worth it. I just had someone ask me the other day if I would make their little girl an apron. I was thinking about one of your brilliant haikus. Almost blurted it out. Instead, though my expression would not have convinced anyone, I said, “Oh I only wish I had the time.” Too bad. One of your haikus would have been much better.
January 27, 2010 at 10:11 am
Pavlina
wow, I have had some pretty good luck with Forever 21. It is a bit of sorting thru the chaff to get the good stuff. Maybe it’s just me, but I would rather buy something like that at Forever 21 and leave my sewing to making more complicated and fun items that are one of a kind.
January 27, 2010 at 1:38 pm
selfishseamstress
Hehe– this *is* complicated for me :)
January 27, 2010 at 10:52 am
Catherine
F21 has had some cute stuff, and some horrid stuff… but overall it’s just made so poorly, and of such terrible fabrics, that I can’t bring myself to purchase anything. Plus I’m coming to realize that if it’s cheap for me, it’s costing someone, somewhere a hellovalt (poor working conditions, working 80 hours a week for a pittance, working underage etc). It’s made me re-think what I need and do not need in my wardrobe, and if I can’t be bothered making it myself, maybe I don’t love it quite so much?? Just question for me to ponder.
That being said, the gray cape top is cute… what would you wear it with? Would you love it if you weren’t quite in love with the fabric? And I have to ask… what SHOES would you wear it with?? ;)
January 27, 2010 at 10:53 am
Catherine
that’s meant to be “costing someone, somewhere a hellovalot”.
January 27, 2010 at 11:04 am
Tenshi
Knockoff of a cheap mall store it might be, but the design is just too cute to be true. This whatever-it-might-be is totally my style.
Would you by any chance share your superiority and enlightement with us lesser beings by writing a how-to on this?
I would absolutely love to make this. I bought waaaayyy to much of that lovely violet wool/cashmere-blend for my new winter jacket anyways…. Unfortunately, I don’t know a thing about pattern drafting…
January 27, 2010 at 1:35 pm
selfishseamstress
If it works out ok, I’ll post the pattern. Sigh, I still have to get around to posting the Parity Dress pattern!
January 27, 2010 at 11:17 am
Kathleen Cooper
Why not re-make a forever 21 garment? Yours will be nicer, and no sweatshop guilt attached. I never sew for anyone else anymore. They do not appreciate how much work and thought goes into the process. As my daughter says, They are Not Worthy.
January 27, 2010 at 11:32 am
AnaJan
Oh I wish you luck Elaine!
Last year I tried knocking off some really cute shift dress in red tartan. It seemed like a simple project. So, I bought a gorgeous wool, which, btw, was far more expensive than the dress itself. I made a muslin, as I wanted to be sure everything fit fine, but I oversaw a minor detail when drafting a muslin: the dress was supposed to be cut on bias, and I made my muslin cut on straight grain. I spent so much time matching plaids, and I really matched them to perfection, but the dress turned out as a wader! Grrrrrrrr!
The bias cut panels pull the fabric in wrong directions, making the dress very unflattering. The dress have been sitting in my closet, never being worn. I can’t force myself to throw it in a trash can, but have no patience anymore to try to fix it. Well, the thing is – I do not know how to fix that mess! Maybe I should post it on BurdaStyle and point out the problems it has – maybe some bias sewing experienced member might help me…
So, I wish you much more luck than I had!
January 27, 2010 at 1:37 pm
selfishseamstress
Eek– sounds like a nightmare, AnaJan, especially in a fabric you’ve totally fallen for. I wish I could help you out, but I’m no bias expert. You could post it on BurdaStyle and ask for advice, but I suspect you’d get more than you bargained for, none of it in agreement with each other ;)
January 27, 2010 at 1:39 pm
Liz
HELP!! Elaine and friends, I implore you to take pity on this poor Selfish Seamstress wannabe!! My daughter has asked me to make her prom dress. ACK! Okay, she’s given me plenty of time, but has some specific requests. She’d like something in a Grecian kind of style, with some braided trim. I think she’s like something like this:http://www.splendicity.com/styleitless/files/2008/07/windowslivewritermattymtwistgreciandress40-a414matty-m-twist-grecian-dress-thumb.jpg
(but floor length and a braided halter neck. I have NEVER drafted my own pattern, and I can’t seem to find a pattern to modify.
Can anyone help??
Thanks!
Liz
January 27, 2010 at 1:44 pm
selfishseamstress
How about combining this:
http://www.burdastyle.com/projects/cate
With the braid from this:
http://www.burdastyle.com/projects/braided-neckline-tank
January 28, 2010 at 6:28 am
Liz
ELAINE! You are a genius and very wonderful to send me those links. I think that will work perfectly!!!
Thanks so very much…
Best,
Liz
January 27, 2010 at 1:49 pm
Angela
I thought I recognized that jacket/cape. It is super cute and can’t wait to see yours!
January 27, 2010 at 1:50 pm
Laura Georgina
I’m with you on the pattern drafting, SS–I get so nervous at messing up fabric that will be wasted (and thus tossed) that I practically shake when I cut into fabric for self-drafted projects. So you are now on the Idolized Sewers list.
BTW, I think it will look lovely in the purple. And BTW 2, I think you should extend the SS merchandise to buttons that can be worn by sewistas to parties where they will invariably be asked by someone or other to make them something. Or reciting your haikus at them, with “for more, see http://www.selfishseamstress.etc“! Hmph. As if.
January 27, 2010 at 2:21 pm
The Slapdash Sewist
I’ve only been in F21 a few times and felt so old I had to leave before my hair turned gray and my teeth fell out. However, I am down with the vest/cape. Will you wear it as an overgarment or a blouse?
January 27, 2010 at 2:27 pm
Rachel
Yours and my mind think alike because I considered knocking that cape off too when I first saw it. I looked around for patterns, but could not find anything close enough to it.
January 27, 2010 at 5:03 pm
Trudy Callan
That is so cute.
January 27, 2010 at 10:34 pm
Reethi
You know, if you don’t want to draft it, you could just buy it, take it apart, and make it so it would fit better. (Can you tell that that is what I’d do?)
January 28, 2010 at 3:00 am
peter
You know, Elaine, if you were nicer to me, I might be convinced to whip up that little number for you.
January 28, 2010 at 6:26 am
Liz
ELAINE! You are a genius and very wonderful to send me those links. I think that will work perfectly!!!
I truly owe you one…
Best,
Liz
January 28, 2010 at 6:45 am
UrbanJill
Yes, knock it off, make it better quality, quit your day job and start posting those patterns
January 28, 2010 at 9:12 am
Miss Celie
You know, I call Forever 21 the ‘Teenage Mom Store’. There is always someone with a stroller in there. I used to pretend I was shopping for my neices. Whatever. I shop there now with impunity. I like the styles. Just not the construction. And, seriously. I called that place Forever 33 this past summer. I’m not even kidding,.
January 28, 2010 at 1:12 pm
Threads
I would first find a pattern for a fitted sleeveless top with a banded neckline like that – I’m sure if you scan old Burdas there will be one, then integrate a cape of choice. That cape looks to me like a half-circle with pleats so you could draft it yourself by calculating the circumference of the neckband, adding in 3 1″ pleats per side (and maybe in the back, too), and using that as the inner circumference of the cape curve. Maybe with a back seam to make the drape even in both sides.
But this site has a ton of cape patterns, which could be adapted:
http://www.patternsoftime.com/products.asp?cat=27
January 28, 2010 at 3:49 pm
juebejue
forever 21 tops are too large for me too!! their skirts are ok if there are xs :) good luck with the knock off, i think yours would be much awesomer. one of the coats i made knocked off a feature of a coat i saw in forever 21.
I love fabric.com, but sometimes the stuff i get is just a total miss. Once instead of a green silk charmeuse, i got a green polyester suede-like fabric. makes me wonder if they had interns who didnt really know fabric running around to find an un-labeld fabric that looks like the one pictured… good that they have awesome return policy!
January 29, 2010 at 12:54 am
Amy
If it really is cheap, I’d be tempted to buy it and rip it apart for a pattern, so I could make it in a nicer fabric. I like to take the easy way out whenever possible.
Very nice style!
January 30, 2010 at 12:59 am
Anonymous
I find there is nothing worse than seeing a brilliant design idea made up in a poor quality fabric. (Goes without saying that a good design is a good design no matter where you find it)
I’d really like to see your version of it.
January 30, 2010 at 7:36 am
Trista
Hi,
Great choice, as some people have indicated, you could buy it and take it apart, it may be easier??? Is this article still available via Forever 21 as I did not locate it on their website and I LOVE IT….
Please let me know how to find it!! Thanks very much!!
February 17, 2010 at 7:07 am
knitsnwovens
Does anyone have pics of something like this being worn? I’m in love with that picture, but I’ve fallen into the trap of “so cute, but feel like a freak when I walk out the door” before… people are pretty slow to pick up on trends around here ;).