For me, there’s a fine line between having something uniquely special and looking crafty-crazy in handmade garments. I certainly am not interested in making something so mundane and generic and unobjectionable that I could buy it at Old Navy for $15. And knocking off something fantastic that is well out of my budget is, of course, totally understandable. But what about the rest of it? The stuff where you start to take more artistic liberty and exercise your creativity? Is it better to make something that looks like it could have come from a nice store, or is it better to make something that you couldn’t possibly get it in a store because it is just that special and unusual? On one hand, it’s flattering when someone thinks your handiwork looks so professional and your choices so on-trend that they say, “That’s a great dress. Is it Banana Republic?” But if you’re going to work hard on developing skills to make one-of-a-kind garments for your own one-of-a-kind self, is it special enough if it looks like commercial clothing you could buy at a chain store? And if it doesn’t look like the sort of thing that any store would sell, do you look a little crafty-crazy when you wear it? (Nothing wrong with looking uniquely artsy-craftsy, of course, but the Selfish Seamstress personally has more conservative taste, so it’s not her style.)
I’ve thought about it a fair bit, and have come up with a heuristic that suits me very well: If it’s not something I would want if I saw it hanging somewhere, then it’s not worth sewing to me. Granted, you can’t know for sure how it will look when it’s done so there’s still some uncertainty. And I don’t think that this is a philosophy that would suit everyone, or that it’s the only way to approach garment sewing. But as a general rule of thumb, it works well for me. My general method for deciding whether to make something is this: Imagine the finished garment made up in the chosen fabric. Imagine that I am not the person who made it. Regardless of whether it’s something that would realistically be sold in a store or not, imagine seeing it hanging on a rack somewhere. Would I want it or not? If it’s something to which I would say, “eh,” then it’s not worth it to me to make it. If it’s something that would set off my crafty-crazy alarm, then it’s also not worth it to me to make it. Don’t get me wrong. I love the process of sewing and that’s mainly why I do it. But I’m not so keen on applying my skills to making garments that I’m not excited about on their own aesthetic merit. And I don’t want to wear something if the only thing I like about it is the fact that I made it myself.
There are a lot of garment “types” that I think hobbyists and crafters make mainly because they appreciate the technique and construction involved, and because they allow them to engage in the process of making. I suspect that these aspects of the process may ultimately be more important to the makers than whether the end product is really the sort of garment that they drool over. Examples of such garments are patchwork vests made by quilters, or most non-lace crocheted sweaters for adults. And I mean no offense whatsoever to quilters or crocheters– I myself have been an avid crocheter for the last 26 years and know that there are some crocheted sweaters that are chic by fashion standards, not just in the crafting community. But let’s face it- most patchwork quilted vests and heavy sweaters of solid double crochet are garments you’re more likely to find hanging from the torsos of hobbyists than in stores, catalogues, (non-crafting) magazines, or anywhere else, and sometimes (not always!) they look a little crafty-crazy. And perhaps the creators of these garments do make them because they really love the aesthetic and this is exactly the sort of garment they want to wear, which is wonderful. Or perhaps they make them, as I hypothesized, mainly because they just want to engage in the making process. If so, more power to these folks- I don’t think there’s anything wrong with this even if it’s not my approach to deciding what to make for myself.
All that being said, I started to wonder: What are the garment projects that hobby sewers undertake because they want to engage in the making rather than because the end product itself is chic? What are the things we make that ultimately only another sewer would find cool? What is our version of the patchwork quilt vest?
[In case you’re wondering where this rambling train of thought came from, it’s because yesterday a couple of folks suggested making a cape or capelet from my sweet potato plaid wool. I’ve been drawn to cape 111 from the August 2009 issue of Burda (pictured up top) since I received the issue, and had actually thought of using the fabric for it. But I’m never sure if capes fall into the crazy-crafter category or whether they’re actually chic (or at least respectable and legitimate) clothing in the real world. Do fashionable women really wear them in real life? Or do hobby seamstresses just sew them and post photos on Pattern Review because we think that if it’s in every other issue of Burda, people must be wearing them? Has the world of sewing penetrated my sense of aesthetics so deeply that I can no longer objectively judge whether certain pieces of clothing look crazy in the real world? If I make the cape, will I be stepping into the world of crafty-crazy that I try so hard to avoid in my wardrobe?]
Update: Thanks for the comments so far! You might be right– plaid + cape might be too much. Here are some samples of plaid capes. Crazy or no?
54 comments
Comments feed for this article
December 28, 2009 at 2:05 am
Mel.J
For me, I think the cape is ok in the fashion stakes. But I think I would go for a plain fabric for a fashion-forward shape. For me, also somewhat conservative, the plaid + the cape would feel like too much. A bit too … Sherlock Holmes?
December 28, 2009 at 2:28 am
redcatbicycliste
I’ve been thinking about making a waterproof cape (or two) so that I can ride my bicycle in the rain. I want something fashionable, which I have not seen from biking-specific manufactured rain gear. Either I sew (and probably design) a cape, or I go to my local hardware store and try to figure out creating a device from parts there that I can attach to my handle bars that will hold a tall and wide umbrella, so that I can ride my bicycle in the rain.
December 28, 2009 at 5:07 am
Kate
I agree with the first commenter. I think the cape in the picture is really cool as a play on the classic trench, and the traditional khaki fabric is what helps me recognize it as a trench. Changing the fabric would put it in a different category for me.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts about sewing and fashion! I’m having fun sewing more of my own clothes, and I enjoy reading your blog.
December 28, 2009 at 6:16 am
Nancy (nanflan)
I agree with the other commenter. You’re going into Sherlock Holmes territory with the plaid and cape, and that’s fine if that’s what you’re going for. However, I suspect that’s a look that’s too costumey for you, given your other comments.
I seldom see someone wearing a cape and when I do, they’re typically very muted colors.
December 28, 2009 at 6:42 am
nancy K
I don’t think that making this in your plaid would be ‘crafty’ at all. I just don’t like capes. I think of them as great to look at but not very easy to wear. Drafty, can’t hang a shoulder bag on it easily, (I’m a shoulder bag wearer) and just often overwhelming on the wearer. There is limited arm movement without a draft. If you live in the South, which you do, then maybe it would work for you. But you are small and the overwhelming factor comes into play here. That great looking model is probably 5’10.
I hate crafty clothing too, but my main criteria is can I get style and comfort in my clothing? I don’t aim for Banana Republic either but that’s because I aim for a better crafted garment than I see in rtw.
December 28, 2009 at 6:40 am
Miss Celie
I’m a capelet suggester and I meant that little cute one from the 9-2009 edition of BWOF. The bit of plaid to me is cute and Anthropologiesque if not a touch twee.
That being said, I freaking love the cape above and have fabric to make it. Just, not the time.
I like my clothes to be a little unique but look like they came from a store. I think the cape above meets that criteria. The hat is what makes it looks a touch silly.
December 28, 2009 at 6:47 am
Miss Celie
I hit refresh and saw said update. My coworker has the first plaid cape you posted. She’s about 5’10 and modelesque. It looks great on her. I, also love the second one you posted. Sigh. I’m no good here. I love both plaid and capes. I will now stop commenting on this post as I cannot be objective ;)
December 28, 2009 at 6:59 am
julie
I don’t think plaid would necessarily be a crazy choice for a cape/caplet. The ones you’ve pictured are terrific! For me, it would depend on how it’s styled. I’d probably stick with wearing it with something casual like denim. And likely forgo the monocle.
December 28, 2009 at 7:58 am
Trudy Callan
The one pictured with the jeans I think looks chic.
December 28, 2009 at 8:08 am
karen
Lady, how much do I love you for using “heuristic” in the context of plaid capes (or at all)? A LOT, that’s how much.
Honestly, I think capes are a no go. I have a hard time envisioning how you’d work a cape into real life. In what situation would you rather be wearing a cape instead of a jacket? How do you carry a bag? Won’t every breeze rearrange your cape into looking like an unmade bed? I worry that capes are in the same category as (non-winter) hats.
This is super fun. I’m so damn happy I ran across your blog.
December 28, 2009 at 9:07 am
beangirl
I actually liked the two examples you gave, because personally I loathe capes and I figure if you’re going to wear one, it should probably be totally crazy and over-the-top. Otherwise they’re just… creepy. Just my opinion, obviously. Lots of people seem to like them. Well, not LOTS of people, but…
Saying that, your plaid isn’t wacky enough to pull off that look. I think your plaid in a cape would be way way bad. Unless you want to look like a nanny from 1932. In which case, you go girl!
December 28, 2009 at 9:08 am
amber
I think some folks bring up a good point that you just don’t want to overwhelm your tiny frame with a huge cape in a busy plaid. That being said, I love the idea of a plaid cape and think that it’s something that can kick up an otherwise conservative outfit, but still stay chic, if that makes any sense. It’s a little bit Anthro, but still maintains a business casual sensibility.
December 28, 2009 at 9:12 am
Liz
Hey! What about a cape using the plaid as an accent? Say, the collar and belt are plaid, the rest a muted brown or cream? I really love plaid, but it’s easy to go overboard. I bought so much plaid at Mood and I’m struggling trying to find ways to use it! =] Good luck!
Liz
December 28, 2009 at 9:26 am
Myra
I like Liz’s idea of plaid as an accent if you decide to go that route. A cape could be nice for jeans or slacks, but since you are small, it needs to be petite-looking, not voluminous. That’s the same thing I wrestle with. I am short, but not skinny, but still have to wrangle with the height issue.
December 28, 2009 at 9:28 am
Myra
Oh and the blue (last photo) is the best one, that would not be “over the top” in the crafty-crazy scheme.
December 28, 2009 at 10:31 am
Susan - Knitters Delight
I don’t know if I would be able to rock the cape or not, but I’d sure try. I really like both plaid versions you pictured and I’m not a huge plaid kinda gal in the first place.
December 28, 2009 at 10:41 am
Karen
I love a girl who makes me go to a dictionary. Thank you for my vocabulary word for the day.
In my world, the only people I have ever known who wear capes are ladies who are too large to be able to find a properly fitting coat or jacket. Being a large lady myself, I would never ever wear one, as I wouldn’t want people making fun of the fat lady who couldn’t find a coat. As for the ones you have pictures above, I think the last photo is very nice, except for that bow. It looks Jackie O to me, and if you have a petite figure you could probably pull it off.
And yeah, even though I am a quilter, I just can’t bring myself to actually wear one.
December 28, 2009 at 10:46 am
Sue
I like the look of capes. I think they are interesting but I will never wear one outside the house. It will look like I am wearing a costume where I live. Plaid is very in right now and I even see it everywhere in the conservative small city I live in. One of my favorite casual garment is a plaid hoodie. I am thinking of making a plaid pencil skirt. I guess it depends on where you live if a plaid cape would be too much.
December 28, 2009 at 10:47 am
Elizabeth
While I personally do not consider capes especially “fashion-forward,” I could easily imagine you pulling off that last cape made up in your plaid (if the scale of the plaid permits it) — you have great style and would know what to wear with it. You would make it look edgy and not crafty-crazy.
If you want to find the truly crafty-crazy sewing, go to those wildly asymmetrical Vogue designer patterns. If you are shuddering just to think about them, you are safe.
December 28, 2009 at 10:59 am
Randi
I’m am very new to the world of sewing. I knew nothing of capes until I discovered Burda and saw some projects that were made. I personally thought it was strange but did like it, perhaps just not for me. That being said during my holiday shopping I did notice some in a major chain store, but there knit. So they might make it into “mainstream”, I’m thinking perhaps starting as an evolved poncho now that they seem to no longer be trendy. I just don’t see how they are really functional still.
December 28, 2009 at 11:15 am
Deb
I live in the Chicago area too, and I think what you do with this may depend on where you spend most of your time. Both suburban and city people are fashionable, but they’re different. I don’t mean to set off a suburban vs urban war, but I think it’s true. The capelet would look good in a solid, especially a black worn with skinny jeans tucked into edgy black boots. Your plaid would look great in a trench or simple coat style, especially with those shoes — the shoes are a great choice, they would really make that plaid coat make sense.
December 28, 2009 at 11:19 am
Pammie
Thanks for the tips – I mentioned you in my blog:) I didn’t take your advice and ended up looking Uber Craftsy.
I saw a very nice plaid suit from Vogue in their December 2009 magazine – I’ll try to see what specifically it is – it would look fantastic with your sweet potato plaid!
December 28, 2009 at 11:25 am
Sunni Standing
Hmmm…It’s a very good question and most eloquently put I must say. I don’t like that crafty crazy look, but then it seems to be what I make the most of. I personally like the plaid capelet, but would probably wear a coat versus a capelet. Go for it. I think it would be more craft crazy if you were to make the capelet out of quilted patchwork.
December 28, 2009 at 11:28 am
Trudy Callan
I see that my awesome sewing blog is missing under “Great Sewing Blogs”
It is http://www.sewingwithtrudy.blogspot.com
If you would like to add my 9 year old daughter’s awesome sewing blog as well, it is Super Stitches at http://www.sewingsister.blogspot.com
December 28, 2009 at 11:34 am
Germania
Hey,
I think the blue cape is ultra-cute. However, the practicality of the cape is in question. In fact, the question is answered. It´s not practical. It does look cute and fun. It´s something I might wear if I were going out and wasn´t carrying anything more than my debit card on me, because as everyone pointed out, it is difficult to carry a shoulder bag with a cape.
I´ve actually crocheted a poncho. I loved the project, I love the look of the garment on me (it´s not a 1970´s poncho. It was from the Double Stitch book), however it is difficult to carry a shoulder purse with it. I have worn it out in public and when I do I feel very dramatic and cool.
I´m 4 feet 11 inches tall. I´m a new sewer and I feel like I want to make clothes that I can´t find at the store either because they were made to fit ME, or because they are a bit too funky (funky as in FANTASTIC). (But I would not wear a chunky crocheted sweater just because I made it…I´ve made things that taught me technique and that I will eventually rip apart to use the yarn on something else.) My poncho is living in a twilight state. It´s something I love (the colors are MINE…heavy on the blue), it´s Funky as in Fantastic, however not practical. I wear it occassionally, but it´s not my go to garment.
A cape, I think would fit in the same category, but may even be more FANTASTIC because, well because it´s a cape and superheros wear capes.
December 28, 2009 at 12:37 pm
The Slapdash Sewist
I made a cape last year and wore it on a trip to Germany but haven’t found a chance to wear it at home. You are limited to a hand-carry clutch with a cape, and it is useful only within a narrow temperature range. That said, I think it’s cute and fun and I feel very Ingrid Bergman/Katharine Hepburn in it (not that I know for sure either of them ever wore capes). Maybe I will wear it over a fancy dress to a wedding in Spring.
Crafty-crazy is certainly not my style. However, not everything I make is Super Special either. I sew all my clothes (except jeans and workout clothes) and sometimes I want to blend in with everyone else, so I make some things that look a little off-the-rack, except that they fit me and are in the exact color I want.
December 28, 2009 at 1:32 pm
beangirl
Ooo, S.S. has a point that I meant to but forgot to make (getting all caught up in the plaid and cape thing). I agree with her in that my intention when making my own clothes isn’t so much to have super-fab clothes or couture garments, it’s to have clothes that look like RTW clothes that you could get at Banana Republic. If Banana Republic deigned to make any of them in my size. Which they don’t.
My goal isn’t to have people notice what I’m wearing because it stands out in some way (good or bad), it’s to have them NOT notice because I look like I got my clothes at some really nice boutique and they fit me really well… which wouldn’t happen if I actually did buy them at some really nice boutique, because they wouldn’t fit.
December 28, 2009 at 3:35 pm
vicki
I would never wear a cape. I would feel silly in it. But they look cute and on someone young it could look very chic. I think plaid would be fine as no doubt you would style it with very simple garments (and those very cute shoes).
December 28, 2009 at 4:33 pm
Sandra
Plaid + cape = awesome!
December 28, 2009 at 4:51 pm
Ellen
I’m not sure I would ever wear a casual cape. Maybe a fabulous velvet or satin one over a formal dress with a great clutch. However, I love the 3 pictures in your post, and the plaid ones are great too. But, as much as I love the sweet potato plaid, I think as a cape it might be a bit over the top.
And I’ve made quilts too, and would not want to wear one. My mom has been known to wear quilted sweatshirt jacket type things. Crafty crazy!
December 28, 2009 at 5:17 pm
ellain
I think the last one would look good ?
December 28, 2009 at 5:54 pm
Christy S
Ah, the cape. Perhaps a neutral wool cape (or I suppose one could make one from twill a la London Fog or Sherlock Holmes) as opposed to a plaid cape if one was actually going to make a cape. I don’t mind them in pictures, I just can’t see myself wearing one. As for out in the real world? Even though in live in Florida (leave your fashion sense at the border please, it’s too hot for of all of that — well, not right now), I have yet to see anyone in a cape. I spent 3 hours at O’Hare a few weeks ago — no capes. Actually the one place I see capes galore is Burda Magazine. I think the big 4 gave up on them last year. Cute on kids and dolls though. Although I may just be anti-cape because I grew up during the 70s and have some deep fashion scars. Leisure suits…polyester…fringed vests…..
December 28, 2009 at 5:59 pm
violet
When I read what you wrote about why someone might choose to make a particular garment, as opposed to buying it from a shop, the thought came to my mind that there are many, many sewers who make their own clothes because the ready-made versions don’t fit their figures. When I decide whether to make or buy, that is one very important factor for me.
As for the capes, they remind me of the recent craze for ponchos. They wouldn’t look good on me, so I reckon a cape wouldn’t either. But if you are being fashion-forward then go for it.
December 28, 2009 at 6:25 pm
Christie
It has always been a dilemma for me- if people ask me-“Did you make that?”, I think that my garment looks too “homemade” If they don’t say anything, I know that I have created something as good as could be found in the stores. But I want everyone to know that I am a skilled, creative sewer!! I want them to ask, but then am a little disappointed when they do.
As for the cape, outerwear is one of my favorite things to sew. Go for it. I would wear it with weekend or more casual attire. With a business suit it would look too stuffy. I like the second example. I made a gray wool cape when I was pregnant years ago. Loved it. It was much more stylish than the nasty maternity coats of the day.
December 31, 2009 at 2:22 pm
meagangracie
I have the same problem – I want people to know I made things, because I’m proud of my efforts, but I don’t want them to look homemade, so I never know if I should be happy or not when people ask if I made something I’m wearing.
I think the quilted jackets come from wanting to be able to show off your mad crafty skills in public for a craft that mainly stays home and inside.
December 29, 2009 at 2:32 am
Noelle
I’d think about 2 things: 1) Do you want to wear a cape for years to come? If yes (which I think that one is pretty awesome). then I think you should make it in a fabric that will be conducive to lots of fashions in the future and also will go with lots of things. I’d stick with the color shown in a plain fabric, or the classic black, or maybe a dark, rich brown.
2) Do you love that fabric more than you love the cape? If yes, make the fabric into something you will also want to wear for years and years.
If no to both at the same time: make the coat out of the orange fabric!
Hope that helps!
December 29, 2009 at 10:25 am
sigrid
A lot of food for thought here. I think that when you have an unconventional style like a cape, a conservative material might work best, like the very small scale, conservative plaids shown. A fuzzy, pumpkin-colored, window-pane plaid will probably look best in a conservative style.
Creating garments that look “hand made”l but not “home made,” and original but not crazy crafty is an ongoing difficulty for me. I often love the idea of making something more than the reality of wearing it.
December 29, 2009 at 10:33 am
Stacey
I do like the blue cape very much, but are those sleeves? It looks like there is a shoulder seam in the picture. Does that mean it’s not a cape? I could totally see a cape worn with tapered jeans and boots, and carrying a pocket book at my elbow. However, how does one wear a cape in the car with a seat belt? I envision it all getting bunched up around my neck and chest so I could lift my arms to drive.
December 29, 2009 at 11:05 am
JustGail
For me, it depends on the plaid and the cape. A cape with a lot of details would be better in a plain fabric, possibly with plaid accents. If it were a simple cape (no pocket flaps, tie belts/collar) a subtle/muted plaid would be wonderful. Or make the outside plain, and go crazy with a wild plaid inside. On the first one, I’d change the pockets to bound pockets to use a plaid, on the 2nd one, change the tie belt to a buckle (or at least make it shorter), the third – I don’t think I’d make one like that no matter what fabric. It just looks like it’s too short all over.
As far as the seam in the blue one, I think I have seen capes with a seam (front only) like a set-in sleeve. Similar to the first cape, except it has a raglan seam in front.
I look forward to seeing what you decide!
December 29, 2009 at 11:41 am
mary nanna
Oh I’m totally guilty of crafty crazy because my only guidelines for sewing something are, “is it fun?” “will I enjoy sewing it?” That’s because first and foremost I see sewing as an artistic process (non-useable item at end) rather than a craft (useable item at end.) Of course I do get annoyed if I can’t or don’t want to wear the item at the end, but it doesn’t stop me being any more practical about my selection. Sewing for me is hobby first. I must have some interest in what I’m making otherwise I’ll just buy it ready made.
December 29, 2009 at 12:47 pm
cape owner/wearer
I live in an urban area. I don’t crochet, nor do I ever don crafty quilt-wear of any type.
I own a black, 100% wool cape (felt type wool) from the 1960s with minimalist lines. It comes down to just below my knees. I wear it with knee-high black leather boots with chunky, square-ish heels or Beatles-style ankle boots and slightly flared jeans. I am 5’6″ and of average weight. I guess some of us cool people can just pull it off. ;)
ps
I agree that a plaid cape would be very Sherlock Holmes, not that here’s anything wrong with that! However, on a petite flower such as yourself, a cape of any type has the danger overwhelming its wearer.
I think plaid works best in small doses, mixed with tweed, denim or heathered wools. I would love to see your plaid made into a chic little jacket with a nipped waist http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_uyYcb8qd7sg/SrwtpTCZx-I/AAAAAAAAAOQ/g1ODDLXbzCs/s1600-h/IMG_3090.JPG
Another option would be to cut the material down to appropriate size, fringe the ends and turn it into a handsome throw blanket for your home.
December 29, 2009 at 5:28 pm
Bunny
OK, there is “crafts crazy” clothing, as you describe it and there is clothing that is fine art. The quilter’s ubiquitous vest is craftsy but there are other garments that are works of art. Summerset Bank’s work comes to mind. The more artistic renditions of one of a kind clothing really lack a name. Is it fiber art? That always makes me think of weaving and felting. What is it? I have seen garments of hand painted silk that are works of art. No way are they “craftsy.” Isn’t the work of any haute couture designer one of a kind and a work of art? I think so. My point here is I would wear any one of a kind garment that is a work of art IN A HEARTBEAT. Does that make me look “craftsy.”? I don’t think so. It is all about perception.
As to your question about engaging in a garment for the sake of making instead of the end product, hmmm. Can’t we have it both ways? I totally enjoy the process but I also totally enjoy the making. I know it is not like that for everyone. I have to say I have garments, rather artistic ones, that I have made, thrilled in the process, enjoyed wearing, and now absolutely enjoy just seeing them hanging in the closet. I think that is OK too.
Very interesting post and comments and thank you for the forum.
December 29, 2009 at 5:30 pm
Bunny
On my last post I meant to say ” I totally enjoy the process but I also totally enjoy the wearing ” (not making, as written). Sorry.
December 30, 2009 at 7:41 am
Ripple Dandelion
I think it is unavoidable that our perception of what looks “right” and what doesn’t shifts as we practice the craft of sewing. I used to worry about becoming a rounded middle aged lady in a quilted vest (or, worse, a holiday-themed, embellished sweatshirt), but as time goes on I care less and less. I realize objectively that my favorite dress, which features creepy Japanese-cute kittens, is not stylish or fashionable, but I enjoy being able to step in some small way outside of the mass market offerings and viewpoint.
I think you would look adorable in a twee little cape, either plaid or solid. I wouldn’t make one myself, being of similar height but plumper than you and also needing a bit more utility from my outerwear. But I would certainly smile if I saw you making your way down the street in one.
December 30, 2009 at 9:04 am
Digs
I’m all for capes, and just made my first one (http://sewing.patternreview.com/cgi-bin/readreview.pl?readreview=1&reviewnum=45987) as an alternative to an indoor jacket, and in glenplaid. I like my jackets to do the talking, and the rest to play the supporting roles, so I have no problems with a plaid cape.
I’d love to make a couple of outerwear versions, and one of them might well be a plaid camel I’ve had in my stash for a while. Then again, it might be its other, plain side. Still, I’ve no problem with plaid capes. And, given the popular culture out there, a couture nod to Sherlock is very timely right now (and, IMO, timeless).
Love that BWOF version you show here – the sleeveless jacket+overcape idea is a great one.
December 30, 2009 at 10:37 am
Junie
I’m particular about clothing and I think the subtle plaid capes in those photos look fantastic and the patterns are beautiful. They do not look “homemade” (if they did, I would not like them — I’m with you on the quilted vests, etc). You could dress those up for work or down for wearing with jeans. And capes are fashionable at the moment. There’s a lady at church who wears a lovely cape (in fashion or not) and always gets compliments on it.
December 30, 2009 at 8:05 pm
Jane
The second plaid cape is gorgeous! Looks fab with simple jeans. I couldn’t carry it off because I’m a bit too chunky but a petite gal like yourself would look great.
Also, I just saw Sherlock Holmes starring Robert Downey Jr and I must say I think Holmes will be making a comeback so there’s nothing mothbally about any references there. I love Downey Jr’s portrayal of an intelligent, slightly insane, yet undoubtedly masculine fallible hero. Swoon.
January 2, 2010 at 8:51 am
6thofdecember
I love 111 Burda cape – I wanted to give it a try but the weather suddenly got cold and I’m back to work on my Ottobre jacket. I suffer from over-craftiness but I think it’s because I grew up in the 70’s when it was cool and groovy to wear granny-square vests and macrame belts. I believe I even wore a quilted vest made from brown calico. I also wore wooden clogs – yes, I was a hippie and proudly sewed my own jean-jumpers. I ditched it all when the punk movement hit and have the piercings to prove it. Anyways, I do try to at least match things nowadays but the call of the crafty haunts me still… I think I have to go visit Etsy now.
January 9, 2010 at 11:13 am
Naan
I love capes, and I’m thinking of making a couple for myself but I always wonder if I’ll end up being stuck with them in a couple of years (considering the fact that they are seasonal garments of course)…..then again, they’re somewhat classic right? Hmmmm.
January 11, 2010 at 5:01 am
Lily
Love this post. I don’t really know anyone else who sews and I’ve only recently encountered “crafty sewers” online, and I know exactly what you mean. I also use your criteria for sewing; I’ll only wear something I’ve made if I would pay at least $300 for it if I saw it in a shop!
I sometimes get a bit paranoid if someone asks me if I’ve made something. Alarm bells go off and I think “Why are they asking me that? Have I done a bad job? Does it look homemade??”. Someone once said of a dress I made (she thought this was a massive complement) “Wow! That’s so nice you could sell it at the markets!”. Displeased.
As for capes… generally speaking I feel they are very crafty crazy, however the examples you have shown are fabulous. Although I feel this one:
http://www.aubinandwills.com/Store/ProductDetails.aspx?ProductRef=003007&Option=003007716
and this one:
http://www.aubinandwills.com/Store/ProductDetails.aspx?ProductRef=003007&Option=003007222
are they ultimate in fantabulousness!
PS Warning: if you check out my blog, my latest post is a little crazy… but that was an art project for uni… the stuff I make to actually wear is right up your alley, I think!
January 11, 2010 at 5:31 pm
Claudine
If you think plaid and cape is a bad combo for you, then it probably is. I made the Burda cape in the first photo on your post and I wear it all the time, but I used a plain camel melton. It feels slightly costume-y, but not too much so, and I like a bit of costume in my wardrobe from time to time.
Here’s my rendition:
http://couturedetails.blogspot.com/2009/10/cape-for-winter.html
Plaid, to my mind, is best left to things that are only worn once in a blue moon, like this:
http://couturedetails.blogspot.com/2009/12/party-dress-season.html
January 27, 2010 at 9:08 am
Forever 33 « The Selfish Seamstress
[…] capelet/vest/jacket thing and now I think I’d like to make one. (I’ve cooled on the Burda cape idea, which I’m taking as an indication that I probably wouldn’t wear it much either if I […]
April 3, 2010 at 5:24 pm
Flirting with crafty crazy: McCall 5525 « The Selfish Seamstress
[…] fun coats, I took this one on with some apprehension because it seemed as though it could veer into crafty crazy territory, a.k.a. calico housecoat. But it’s actually looking ok so far- it looks less crazy on me than […]
April 7, 2010 at 5:34 pm
Jodi
Hehe. This post really made me laugh. When I was a teenager a lot of the clothes I made were really crazy (super shiny metallic fabric, sequins, really flared pants, huge bat wing sleeves) – nothing that was in fashion at the time at all. I didn’t care what people thought of my fashion choices, I felt much more free than I do now.